|
|
MOLD - Hype
or Real Risk?
The air we breathe - just how
safe is it? How do we know when we should be concerned? Words and phrases
like indoor air quality (IAQ), respiratory distress, aggravated asthma conditions, increased incidence of
asthma, allergies, mold, mildew, dust mites, pollen, air cleaners, ventilation,
and duct cleaning are more and more a part of our conversations.
Increasingly, we are talking
about specific kinds of mold, not just old mold. Is this a new problem or just one that our technology is now
allowing us to detect more effectively? Are we overreacting or should
we be concerned? If we should be concerned, what products or actions are most
effective? Unfortunately, there is not a simple answer. We do have better technology that allows us to understand and
analyze more of the world around us. Some of the air quality issue is simply
because we know more about it. However, it is also true that
we are building homes and buildings that are more vulnerable to conditions
that promote the growth of mold. It is also true that mold is one of the most common causes of frequently reported
respiratory problems. The following is intended to provide an overview of
what we know about mold and what we can do about it. Before you take any
action in your own home or building, however, you should consult a local
specialist: a building inspection engineer. The problem of mold is one
that no building owner or manager can afford to ignore. Mold has been
suggested as one possible factor in so-called Sick Building Syndrome. The
unusual weather conditions in many parts of the United States in recent years
have provided good conditions for the growth of toxigenic fungi and increased
the potential for human exposure. Throughout the country, deaths of children
from pulmonary hemosiderosis (bleeding lung disease) have been attributed to
inhalation of toxins produced by the fungus Stachybotrys chartarum. The U.S. Department of Housing
and Urban Development awarded $3.1 million to the city of Cleveland to
remediate mold and moisture problems in houses and apartments. Mold problems in the Martin County Courthouse
in Florida apparently caused by a leaky EIFS (exterior insulation finish
system) facade cost $26 million to remediate. The building cost $13 million to construct a
few years earlier. An old school
building in Canada, infested with toxigenic fungi, had to be burned. Mold is a problem. What is mold? The words mold and
mildew are sometimes used interchangeably. If there is a difference in the
two terms, it is that mildew generally refers to a fungus-caused discoloration of an underlying, porous material, whereas
mold refers to a fungus growth on a porous, often rotting material.
Essentially, mold is the growth produced by several types of fungi as they feed on organic matter.
Mold typically reproduces asexually by means of airborne spores. These spores
are always present in the air. There are thousands of types of fungi
(mold). Many fungi are helpful. Some
good types of fungi are those used to produce Camembert and Roquefort
cheeses. The wonder drug penicillin is a by-product of the fungus Penicillium
notatum. What does it need from us?
Like all living things, mold
spores need certain conditions to reproduce and grow. Mold needs water, food, and the right
temperature range. Mold grows better in a dark environment, and with an organic, porous material to grow
on. Such material often provides a
source of both food and water. Unfortunately, buildings
provide an almost ideal environment to support the growth of mold. The
typical temperatures are right, and there are plenty of dark places and
organic substances. Just add water, and you’ve created a perfect mold
breeding ground. Dry rot, a common condition in
older homes, is bacterial activity similar to mold and needs the same
combination of conditions for ideal growth.
If you have dry rot, you probably have mold.
The reverse is true as well. Why should we be concerned?
Mold can feed on and destroy
most of the organic materials found in buildings such as wood, paper, carpet,
and glue. However, almost any surface can support the growth of mold. Although mold can be found anywhere, it typically
grows in dark, moist places such as behind walls or in HVAC ducting. Mold can cause harmful health
effects in humans. Although the species Stachybotrys chartarum (sometimes
referred to as stacky for short) has received most of the recent press, many other types of fungi are potentially harmful
to humans as well. For this reason, Stachybotrys chartarum is not treated as
a unique case. One bit of good news: although
Stachybotrys chartarum is considered one of the more hazardous forms of mold,
its spores are wet and slimy. That makes it a bit easier to visually identify and much less likely to become airborne.
Stachybotrys chartarum is usually transferred by contact with insects or
rodents or by water. Exposure to fungus can cause
organic dust toxic syndrome (ODTS) or hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP). ODTS
may occur following a single exposure to high concentrations of dust
contaminated by fungus, such as might be encountered during remediation or
renovation work. The symptoms are flu-like. HP occurs as a result of
prolonged exposure and can lead to permanent lung damage. Exposure to fungus can also
cause allergic reactions: typically a runny nose, sneezing, eye irritation,
cough, or aggravation of asthma. What should I look for?
Mold is not only a problem in
itself but also a symptom of a water problem. The first step in any investigation for the presence of mold in
buildings is to follow the water. Look for evidence of high
humidity, condensation, or visual evidence of water staining. Mold grows in
dark, hidden places, such as behind walls, and may not always be visible. Other clues, such as musty odors or reported
physical symptoms in occupants, should be noted. How do I know if I have a mold problem?
If you see mold or evidence of
moisture accumulation, test the suspect material. Testing, in order to
identify the particular species of mold, can be performed by a number of laboratories. The EPA has recently developed a
DNA-based testing procedure that dramatically reduces the time it takes to
identify which of the 100 or so most common mold species may be present. Using this technology, tests that used to
take days or weeks can now be performed in a matter of hours. Information on
the EPA testing method is available at http://www.epa.gov. Consultants and laboratories
are listed under environmental laboratories or industrial hygienists in the
yellow pages. Such firms can usually help with mitigation as well, should that be necessary. How can I minimize the risk of mold?
Because mold likes the same
temperature as humans, changing the ambient temperature as a method of
control is not usually an option. It is hard to eliminate the
molds food source entirely, because it feeds on a wide range of materials
commonly used in building construction and interior finishes. However, because mold can feed on dirt, cleanliness can go a long
way toward control. The easiest way to minimize
mold growth is to eliminate sources of water. Moisture in a building can exist in two forms, as humidity and
as free water. Moisture may come from
inside the building through condensation,
plumbing leaks, cooking, showers, or the HVAC system. Water may enter
the building from the outside through leaks in the roof, the facade, or the
basement. Water also may be introduced into the building through the use of wet building
materials such as roofing materials, insulation, and drywall. If you identify any of these
sources of water or moisture, you should take immediate steps to eliminate
them. This may require modifications to the structure, improved ventilation, improved environmental controls (HVAC),
improved surface drainage, or any one of many other possibilities. You should
consult a qualified building inspection engineer for advice. How can I remediate an existing problem?
Any plan to remediate mold
must first address solving the water problem. The source of the moisture must be identified and the condition
rectified. Only then should the process of remediation begin. Remediation consists of either
cleaning the affected materials in place or the removal and replacement of
these materials. The decision of whether to clean or replace is largely an economic one, based on the size of the areas
affected, the ease of access, and whether or not the building components have
been damaged by either mold or water. If the buildings structural
components are not damaged, small areas can usually be remediated by
homeowners or maintenance staff. Trained contractors, however, should handle larger areas. Dealing with extensive areas
of mold is like handling any other hazardous material and requires specific
training. The New York City Department of Health publishes
a useful guide titled Guidelines on Assessment and Remediation of Fungi in
Indoor Environments. It is available on line at http://www.ci.nyc.ny.us/html/doh/html/epi/moldrpt1.html Other ways of dealing with
large infestations are being tested. At least one company treats moldy houses
by enclosing them and raising the interior temperature in a controlled manner to about 160ˇ F. This effectively bakes
the mold and kills it. Most air cleaners (purifiers,
ionizers, etc.) are not effective in dealing with a mold problem. At best,
such equipment deals with the symptom rather than the cause. Summary
For help with mold problems or
suspected mold problems, the first step is to contact an engineer who is
qualified to perform the diagnostics necessary to determine the root cause of the problem. Determining the cause of the
problem, whether that is a leaky roof, facade issues, excess humidity, or a
malfunctioning HVAC system, is often a complex process of detective work.
There are often false leads, and inexperienced people often mistake effect
for cause, leading to a misdiagnosis. Breathing is essential to
life. It is not an option. Breathing contaminated air can lead to respiratory
irritations and, for some, can be life threatening. It is time well spent to inspect the buildings in which you live and work to
determine if there are any suspect conditions that might lead to a mold
infestation. If there are, testing, source identification, and remediation should follow quickly. For the office nearest you, call 1-800-242-1969
YOUR HOME is your link to the nations
oldest inspection service, with affiliate offices staffed exclusively by
registered engineers and architects
professionals committed to serving your needs. CRITERIUM ENGINEERS was
founded in 1957. Copyright © 2001 by
CRITERIUM ENGINEERS. Reproductions in any form without express, written
consent are prohibited. For additional copies or more information, contact CRITERIUM ENGINEERS, 22 Monument Square - Suite
600, Portland, ME 04101.
Criterium
Engineers, Copyright © 1999 Close Articles of Interest |